May 31, 2023
Ithaca, NY | 83°F


Campus reacts to restrictions on journalists

Ithaca College faculty and students are responding to a new media policy issued by President Tom Rochon that requires all student media to route requests for interviews with administrators through the college’s office of media relations.

Under the new policy, which went into effect Monday, all media interested in contacting an administrator, director, dean, associate dean or assistant dean must contact Dave Maley, associate director of media relations, who will facilitate an interview.

Rochon informed Ithacan editors of the new policy in a meeting Sept. 24. He sent out an email Sept. 28 to editors of The Ithacan, WICB, ICTV and Buzzsaw Magazine explaining the new policy, which states that reporters from student media who are reporting on topics of college policies and developments must go through the office of media relations.

The email included a list of 84 members of the college’s Administrative Assembly who are affected by this policy. Those administrators were informed about the policy at a meeting Sept. 11.

Wenmouth Williams, chair of the journalism department at the college, said though the new procedure does not apply to faculty, it affects their work environment.

“It’s affected what we think about the culture in which we work, which obviously has an impact on our excitement, job satisfaction issues — you know, the kind of unmeasurables that are primary reasons for us being here in the first place,” he said.

In an interview Sept. 25, Maley said if an administrator is contacted directly by a reporter, the administrator must redirect the inquiry to the media relations office.

Rochon said in the email to student media that the policy is meant to curb a “tendency to rely too much on just a few people” which, he said, distracts them from their “actual jobs.”

Maley said the new requirements are not intended to control media access.

“To best facilitate being able to answer questions and find the best person to represent the institution, the general media policy is for reporters and members of the media to go through the media relations office in order to facilitate interviews with administrators at the college,” he said.

He said external media already tend to operate this way, and that instituting this requirement for college media was simply a formalization of the practice. The policy will not apply to students writing stories for classes.

The Ithaca College student media, however, have always had open access to administrators, faculty and staff at the college, directly contacting the sources they find appropriate for stories.

Claudia Wheatley, communication manager in the office of press relations at Cornell University, said Cornell has no formal media policy. Student reporters can contact administrators directly or go through media relations.

“It’s up to our administrators to decide whether to respond directly or refer them to press relations,” she said in an email.

Peter Rothbart, professor of music theory, history and composition and chair of the faculty council, said he thinks the college is taking a business approach to media.

“The college can be run as a business; it can also be run as an educational institution,” he said. “I prefer the educational institutional approach to this.”

Maley said though administrators who fail to follow the procedure will not be penalized, the policy is not optional.

Initial email correspondence between the reporter and the source is also included in the policy. Maley said he will serve as a middleman, receiving emails from reporters, sending them to administrators, receiving the response from administrators and finally sending the responses to the reporter.

“That would come through me,” he said.

Williams said the new procedure could slow down the publication process for media at the college.

“If it’s anything that is timely, going through a bureaucracy to get info or not being allowed to get the information really cuts down on your ability to be a journalist,” he said.

Senior Nicole Ogrysko, news director for WICB and senior writer for The Ithacan, said the new policy will not affect WICB too much because the radio station tends to focus more on news outside of the college. However, it will affect her as a reporter for The Ithacan.

“It’s going to take forever to talk to anybody for anything,” she said. “If we can’t get someone to respond to us within two days [now], then I don’t know how we’re going to get them to respond by going through a second person who’s probably going to get bombarded by everybody anyway.”

The Student Government Association passed a resolution, “New Media Policy Repeal,” Monday in response to the new policy. The document states that SGA “formally recommends the new media policy be repealed.” Sixteen senators voted in favor of the resolution, two voted against it and one abstained. The resolution was sent to Rochon at noon Wednesday.

Senior Rob Flaherty, president of SGA, said most students oppose the policy because it could potentially lead to media censorship.

“They say they are not going to do this, and I want to believe that, but giving the administration that much authority is not something that I or many of the students I’ve talked to are comfortable with,” he said.

Jeff Cohen, director of the Park Center for Independent Media, is one of the directors on the list. He said the new protocol is reminiscent of corporate media relations strategies, and that he is not clear on what the problem is that the college wants to address.

“The jury is out in terms of if they can explain what problem this is intending to fix,” Cohen said. “The policy seems more a communications policy for a corporation or a government agency than a college campus.”

Maley also said, though he would make recommendations on who would be the most appropriate source, he would not directly prevent reporters from reaching out to any particular sources.

“I won’t be serving as a gatekeeper in that way,” he said.

He said this “reaching out” could only be done through him, however.

Maley, who will be coordinating interviews for all 84 listed administrators with the media, said he is hoping the new procedure will be efficient for everyone involved.

“It will be our job to ensure that we are not slowing things down and getting in the way,” he said.

In addition to his other concerns about the policy, Williams said adopting the new policy sends the wrong message to prospective student journalists who may want to enroll at the college.

“How am I, as a person who is responsible for managing the journalism department, [going to] talk to prospective students about studying journalism here?” he said. “I haven’t come to grips with that yet … it’s a potential black eye. It’s a potential public relations disaster.”

Repeated attempts to contact Rochon, through Maley, for comment this week were unsuccessful.

Editor’s note: This article is an updated and expanded version of the Sept. 28th article, “Rochon implements new media access policy.”